The End of the Honeymoon, the Start of the Marathon

Why seizing Congress is the easiest part for the Democrats, and why real accountability begins the day after victory?

Jose Del Real had not voted in ten years. The veteran, who had served in Iraq, lived in southwestern Kansas, where Republican victories had long seemed inevitable to him. Then immigration agents arrived. Del Real spoke with angry and anxious neighbors and urged them to turn their discontent into votes. The result was striking. Adam Hamilton, a Democrat, defeated Roger Marshall, the Republican incumbent, and Kansas gained its first Democratic senator in 94 years.

This account is not merely a report on a close political race. It shows how government decisions can draw people back into public life, including those who expected little from politics. But increased participation is not the same as restored trust. The November midterms handed control of both chambers of Congress to the Democrats, yet they did not clarify what voters want from the party or whether they believe it can change how the country is governed.

That distinction must now set the course for the new Congress. Voting against the party in power can register anger without endorsing a full replacement. Democrats now hold the power to investigate, to legislate, and to constrain the president. But their harder task is to show that these powers can make government more accountable and answer those who see no reason to trust Washington.

That must be the meaning of de-Trumpification. Not removing one man from public life, and not trying to reverse every policy tied to his era, but making it harder for any president to govern through intimidation, concealment, or disregard for legal boundaries. And making clear why those boundaries matter beyond the walls of Congress. They determine who bears the cost of public decisions, who benefits from them, and whether people can object to how the government treats them.

Stay ahead of the geopolitical week.

MD Briefing delivers expert analysis across five global fronts — the Indo-Pacific, energy, geoeconomics, European security, and the Middle East — every Monday morning. Free.

The election does not give Democrats a blank check. In the October AP-NORC poll, roughly four in ten adults held a favorable view of the Democratic Party, while nearly eight in ten voters wanted significant change or a complete overhaul in how the country is run. These two findings point in different directions. Voters may want change without feeling much attachment to the party now responsible for delivering it.

Congressional oversight, then, must be more than a string of noisy hearings. When lawmakers investigate a federal contract, an immigration operation, or a decision to deploy military force, they must clarify what authority was invoked, what it cost, and whether officials complied with the law. They must publish their findings transparently, act to remedy abuses when the evidence warrants it, and refrain from announcing conclusions before the work is done. This approach may be quieter than daily confrontation with the White House, but it is more likely to answer the real questions people ask. Who made this decision? Who benefited? Who paid the cost? And what happens next?

Purchasing power is one of the most immediate tests. The Bureau of Labor Statistics reported that consumer prices rose 0.4 percent in October, following a 0.6 percent increase in September. A slower monthly increase does not mean prices are falling, and no monthly indicator fully captures the real pressure on a family that loses a larger share of its income as rent, groceries, or energy bills climb. These statistics matter, but they do not replace understanding that experience.

Congress cannot bring prices down by decree, and Democrats cannot guarantee that any law will pass while Trump is president. But they can make the country’s choices visible. They can propose plans on the cost of housing and health care, examine the effect of tariffs and energy policy, and explain who is likely to bear the cost of the administration’s decisions. When the president rejects a proposal, voters should be able to see what was offered and why it failed. That is a more honest use of congressional power than promising economic relief without saying how it would be achieved.

The war with Iran makes the importance of oversight especially clear. In a Reuters/Ipsos poll conducted shortly after the election, 71 percent of respondents said they wanted Congress to pass legislation to end the conflict. This is not a mandate for lawmakers to claim they can end the war themselves; it is a reason to force the administration to explain its objectives, its costs, and its plan for ending the fighting. Congress has tools to pursue those answers. It can hold hearings, examine the legal basis for military action, and use its control over federal spending to challenge the continuation or expansion of the conflict. None of these steps guarantees that the war will end, but they make it harder to keep a fateful decision confined to the private domain of the executive. The goal is not to turn oversight into a spectacle of humiliation; the goal is to clarify what the country has been asked to support and at what cost.

The Kansas story also raises a difficult question about immigration. Congress need not pretend that law enforcement has no purpose or treat every disruptive operation as a sign of government effectiveness. It can examine whether agencies acted lawfully, whether people have a meaningful way to challenge errors, and what effect sudden enforcement campaigns have on families and local communities. These are not marginal issues in a discussion of democracy. For those who encounter the government at work, at home, or in their neighborhood, the rule of law is not an abstract concept.

Yet constitutional safeguards cannot be defended merely as a way to lower next month’s bills. Congress has an independent responsibility to protect elections, scrutinize the conduct of the executive branch, and defend its own authority over public spending. The challenge is to make these responsibilities comprehensible without claiming it can solve every problem. Procedures matter because their collapse can narrow the paths people have to object to decisions that shape their lives.

The results among young voters are another reason for caution. An AP voters’ survey found that voters aged 18 to 29 supported Democratic House candidates by roughly 73 to 25 percent. A Tufts University analysis also showed a strong Democratic advantage among young voters, with the caveat that people under thirty made up only about 11 percent of the electorate. This shift is significant, but it is not a permanent guarantee of support. Young voters, like others, will judge Congress by what it does next.

Del Real’s return to the ballot box began with the belief that his vote, where he lives, could matter. Congress should not mistake that participation for a final verdict on the future of American democracy. The midterms constrained Trump’s political power, but they did not eliminate the conditions that made his politics attractive. Democratic renewal depends on lawmakers making power accountable, public costs visible, and government more responsive to those who have learned not to trust its promises.

Peter Rodgers
Peter Rodgers
My name is Peter Rodgers and I am a writer here and there on this and that. But I am particularly keen on the United States' foreign policy. I follow all the news and developments regarding the United States relations with Europe, Middle East, and the Indo-Pacific region and my writings have appeared on websites like responsiblestatecraft.org. Currently, I spend most of my time reading and sometimes writing. When I am not reading and writing, I either watch basketball or play basketball. I was born and raised in Canada where I am currently based but I am very much interested in traveling the world and actually see the countries that I am reading and writing about. I did my degree in international relations at Penn States University. You can find me at conferences and events about United States foreign policy and international relations.