Can Britain Rebuild Ties With the EU Without Reversing Brexit?

Britain and the European Union are preparing to take another step towards closer relations, with an upcoming summit expected to produce agreements on food trade and defence cooperation.

Britain and the European Union are preparing to take another step towards closer relations, with an upcoming summit expected to produce agreements on food trade and defence cooperation. The discussions reflect a significant shift in Britain’s post-Brexit approach under Prime Minister Andy Burnham, who has reopened the debate about the country’s long-term relationship with the bloc.

Ten years after the 2016 Brexit referendum, both sides appear increasingly willing to move beyond the political bitterness that defined their separation. However, the negotiations also expose the difficult choices facing London: closer access to the European market could benefit British businesses, but it may require accepting EU rules and limiting some of the regulatory independence that Brexit was intended to secure.

The expected agreements are therefore an early test of whether Britain can strengthen its European partnerships without committing to a return to EU membership.

Why Are Britain and the EU Moving Closer?

European leaders have welcomed Burnham’s willingness to reconsider Britain’s relationship with the bloc, arguing that the changing geopolitical environment makes closer cooperation increasingly important.

Stay ahead of the geopolitical week.

MD Briefing delivers expert analysis across five global fronts — the Indo-Pacific, energy, geoeconomics, European security, and the Middle East — every Monday morning. Free.

The summit is expected to focus on linking food and carbon markets, alongside a commitment to strengthen defence cooperation. These arrangements could reduce trade barriers and improve coordination in areas where Britain and the EU share economic and security interests.

However, the negotiations remain incomplete. Disagreements over the proposed youth mobility scheme and university tuition fees mean the wider package is unlikely to be formally signed off for another six months.

Burnham has acknowledged that agreements across the different areas must be reached before the package can be approved. The delay illustrates the complexity of rebuilding institutional ties after years of political and regulatory separation.

Relations have nevertheless improved considerably since the difficult Brexit negotiations. One EU diplomat described the current atmosphere as more positive, pointing to Britain’s willingness to align its food regulations with EU standards as evidence that practical cooperation is becoming possible.

The Economic Costs and Benefits of Brexit

Britain’s post-Brexit economic experience remains central to the debate over closer European ties.

Since leaving the bloc in 2020, the United Kingdom has pursued independent trade agreements with countries including Australia, New Zealand and India. It has also attempted to improve access to European markets while developing a separate regulatory framework in sectors such as artificial intelligence, financial services and agriculture.

However, maintaining access to the EU market has remained difficult. British food and drink exports to the bloc were almost a third lower in 2025 than in 2019, highlighting the commercial consequences of new trade barriers and regulatory differences.

For British businesses, closer alignment could reduce administrative costs, simplify cross-border trade and make exports more competitive. Food producers in particular could benefit from arrangements that reduce the need for additional checks and regulatory procedures.

Yet Brexit supporters argue that regulatory independence remains an important advantage. They point to Britain’s ability to establish rules tailored to its own economic priorities rather than automatically following decisions made in Brussels.

The central question is whether the economic benefits of closer integration would outweigh the loss of some of that independence.

Regulatory Independence Creates Difficult Choices

Artificial intelligence provides one example of the differences between Britain’s approach and the EU’s regulatory model.

London has favoured a relatively light-touch framework, closer to the approach associated with the United States. The EU, by contrast, has developed a risk-based regulatory system that imposes different requirements depending on the potential risks posed by AI applications.

Agriculture presents another challenge. A British regulator has approved pesticides for use in the cereal sector that have not received approval in Brussels. Any move towards greater regulatory alignment could therefore affect domestic agricultural practices.

The British farmers’ union wants any withdrawal of such products to happen gradually rather than through an immediate ban. It also wants Britain to retain a voice in decisions affecting its agricultural sector.

These disagreements demonstrate why closer ties cannot be treated as a straightforward economic adjustment. Regulatory alignment may improve access to European markets, but it can also require Britain to reconsider domestic policies and accept standards over which it has limited influence.

Analysts argue that these choices will become increasingly difficult as negotiations expand beyond food and carbon markets into other sectors of the economy.

Defence Cooperation and the ‘Made in Europe’ Question

Security cooperation is expected to feature prominently at the summit, reflecting the changing strategic environment in Europe.

Britain remains an important European military power, and closer defence coordination could strengthen the continent’s ability to respond to shared security challenges. Russia’s aggression and wider geopolitical instability have also encouraged European governments to reconsider the importance of cooperation with London.

However, economic and industrial interests will complicate the discussions. Britain wants clarification on whether its automotive industry could benefit from the EU’s proposed “Made in Europe” initiative, which is intended to protect European manufacturers from cheaper Chinese imports.

The issue is particularly important for British manufacturers, who risk being disadvantaged if European industrial protection measures exclude companies based outside the EU.

The negotiations therefore extend beyond diplomatic relations. They could influence the competitiveness of British industries and determine how closely the country remains connected to Europe’s emerging economic and security arrangements.

What Will Burnham Promise Before the Next Election?

The longer-term direction of Britain’s relationship with the EU will depend partly on what Burnham commits to in his Labour Party’s next election manifesto, which must be presented by 2029 at the latest.

For now, the prime minister remains constrained by existing party commitments that favour closer cooperation without promising a return to membership.

Some European policy analysts argue that substantial economic benefits would eventually require Britain to consider full EU membership. However, European officials do not expect such a development in the immediate future.

Rejoining would involve difficult negotiations and acceptance of the bloc’s core principles, including freedom of movement. Britain would also have to reconsider its position on the single market, which offers substantial economic advantages but requires members to follow common rules.

Financial services could be a particularly sensitive issue. Britain is unlikely to accept arrangements that leave it following EU regulations without having a meaningful role in shaping them.

According to a person familiar with Burnham’s thinking, he believes closer European ties could support economic growth, strengthen defence and security, and help address irregular migration across the English Channel.

Public opinion may provide some political support for this approach. Polling indicates that a majority of Britons favour rejoining the EU, although support declines when voters are asked to consider the financial costs and lengthy negotiations that membership would involve.

What Happens Next?

The upcoming summit is unlikely to resolve the fundamental disagreements surrounding Brexit. Instead, it represents an attempt to rebuild cooperation gradually through sector-specific agreements.

For Britain, the challenge is to secure better access to European markets while preserving the regulatory flexibility and independent trade relationships developed since leaving the bloc. For the EU, the priority will be to strengthen cooperation without allowing Britain to enjoy the benefits of membership while avoiding its obligations.

The wider geopolitical environment has made both sides more receptive to compromise. However, improved diplomatic relations do not automatically translate into an agreement on the economic and political terms of closer integration.

The immediate outcome will depend on whether negotiators can resolve disagreements over mobility, education, food standards and industrial cooperation. The more consequential question will be whether Burnham is prepared to make closer European integration a central commitment of his next electoral programme.

A decade after the Brexit referendum, Britain is once again confronting the trade-offs between sovereignty, economic access and European cooperation. The direction it chooses could shape its economic and strategic position for years to come.

With information from Reuters.

Sana Khan
Sana Khan
Sana Khan is the News Editor at Modern Diplomacy. She is a political analyst and researcher focusing on global security, foreign policy, and power politics, driven by a passion for evidence-based analysis. Her work explores how strategic and technological shifts shape the international order.