With less than two months left in Antonio Guterres’ tenure as UN secretary-general, the United Nations faces a potential leadership vacuum as no successor has been agreed upon. The UN Security Council plans to conduct another secret ballot this week following eight rounds of voting without a decision. Officials are now preparing contingency plans for the possibility of having no leader when Guterres’s term ends on December 31.
The slow progress in selecting a new secretary-general is attributed to the complicated selection process, which relies on secret ballots and has faced gridlock. The council took six rounds to elect Guterres in 2016. The current stalemate reflects a broader unwillingness among the five permanent members, possessing veto power, to reach a compromise, a situation worsened by a US administration that has been distancing itself from the UN amidst its foreign policy challenges.
The candidates for the leadership position include established UN professionals, such as Rebeca Grynspan, who is currently seen as the frontrunner, and Lana Nusseibeh from the UAE, who faces criticism regarding her country’s alleged support of the Rapid Support Forces in Sudan’s civil war, which the UAE denies. The next secretary-general will inherit significant challenges, including ongoing global conflicts, reduced US funding, the diminishing influence of the UN, and calls for the organization to become more efficient and accountable.
Experts suggest that failing to elect a new secretary-general by year-end would signal serious issues within the UN and fuel criticisms from member states questioning the competency of the permanent members. The P5 nations, which include Britain, China, France, Russia, and the US, have retained their power since World War II, despite many members feeling that the structure does not reflect current geopolitical realities.
Stay ahead of the geopolitical week.
MD Briefing delivers expert analysis across five global fronts — the Indo-Pacific, energy, geoeconomics, European security, and the Middle East — every Monday morning. Free.
The UN Charter does not outline procedures for handling a leadership vacancy, making this situation unprecedented, as no secretary-general has ever left without a designated replacement. A recent report from 1 for 8 Billion explored various possible scenarios, such as appointing an acting chief or having the General Assembly extend Guterres’s term, but all options have challenges.
The current selection process, involving extensive lobbying and multiple rounds of secret straw polls, is seen as outdated in today’s digital world. The council’s voting process is not transparent, with results usually leaked but never officially disclosed. Critics argue that this lack of clarity is not an appropriate method for selecting the world’s chief diplomat. Guterres, having lost influence with both Washington and Moscow, is viewed by some as lacking the necessary impact to lead effectively.
As the deadline approaches, some members, including Russia, have raised concerns about what will happen after December 31. If no new secretary-general is appointed, operations could continue, but many essential functions would be unmanageable without formal leadership. The situation raises questions about the future functioning of the UN and the responsibilities of its leadership.
With information from Reuters

