After nearly nine months of war, the United States and Iran find themselves in a stalemate where both believe they can outlast the other. This situation is dangerous, as some officials worry fighting might resume before talks can lead to a resolution. U.S. President Donald Trump has decided to apply pressure on Iran through a naval blockade and economic sanctions instead of renewing military strikes, which he believes would not change the situation and could provoke Iranian retaliation against Gulf oil infrastructure.
In contrast, Iranian leaders feel encouraged by recent political setbacks faced by the Trump administration and Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu. They have made their demands more stringent, expecting the U.S. to take the first steps toward a peace deal. While Iran expresses a willingness to negotiate and is meeting with Omani and Qatari mediators, they accuse the U.S. of trying to force them into submission and refuse to bend to U.S. pressure.
Experts note that both sides have unrealistic expectations about what it would take to end the conflict. The U.S. demands are seen as too costly for Iran, while Iran’s conditions are politically unfeasible for Washington. Some European officials have pointed out that the U.S. military actions have backfired, strengthening Iran and complicating the nuclear issue rather than resolving it.
According to intelligence, a significant amount of Iran’s enriched uranium may be hidden deep underground, making it difficult for the U.S. to address its nuclear ambitions even as Iran claims its program is for peaceful purposes. Iran refuses to allow nuclear inspectors to return while hostilities continue.
Stay ahead of the geopolitical week.
MD Briefing delivers expert analysis across five global fronts — the Indo-Pacific, energy, geoeconomics, European security, and the Middle East — every Monday morning. Free.
In making decisions, Washington is considering its options, which include escalation, negotiation, capitulation, or further economic pressure. Currently, it appears the U.S. is focusing on economic pressure, which they believe is severely impacting Iran and reducing the need for military action. However, Secretary of State Marco Rubio has stated that there is an option to apply sustained economic pressure while still aiming for a balanced agreement, highlighting that military action remains a possibility if Iran does not yield.
The Gulf states have warned that renewed U.S. military action could lead to Iranian retaliation against their infrastructure. They have advised against an attack, which aligns with Trump’s approach to avoid direct conflict. Trump has a brief opportunity to act while military assets are in the region, but it remains uncertain if he will take decisive action.
Ongoing discussions between the U.S. and Iran face hurdles, particularly regarding the sequencing of actions needed to move forward. Iran wants immediate lifting of the blockade and the release of frozen assets before substantive negotiations begin, while the U.S. seeks mutual commitments. The path to a deal may come only if both nations can make concessions to third parties, particularly the Gulf states, which could help bridge the gap between U.S. and Iranian expectations.
Internally, Iranian politics pose challenges for negotiating a deal. Hardliners within Iran’s leadership are resistant to compromise, complicating the efforts of negotiators who are trying to reach an agreement. Analysts have noted that any sign of weakness in negotiations could negatively impact the standing of officials involved. Ultimately, if the U.S. maintains its naval blockade, Iran may be forced to escalate its actions, as they may not be able to endure the pressure indefinitely.
With information from Reuters

